No dog owner wants their dog to attack another pet or person, but hundreds of attacks happen every year despite the best efforts of many pet owners. The severity of dog attacks can vary from a minor bite to a severe injury or even death of the victim. Determining who was at fault for the dog attack is often a necessary part of dealing with the aftermath of an incident.
Every dog attack is an individual situation and fault can lie with any party who is involved in the attack. The unique circumstances that caused the attack play a large part in determining who is actually at fault. Fault must be determined on a case-by-case basis. In an incident where the owners of the dog and the victim cannot agree who is at fault, the determination may be made by authorities such as the police or judge.
Several key factors come into play when determining fault for a dog attack. Obviously, the dog who did the attacking must come under scrutiny. The dog's past behavior is often brought up as a way of determining whether the attack could have been anticipated by a reasonable owner. Dogs who have a history of aggressive behavior, have previously attacked other animals or humans or have otherwise been labeled as aggressive need to be cared for differently than dogs who are not considered aggressive.
Once the dog's past behavior has been assessed by the authorities in charge of determining fault, the owner's actions in preventing an attack will be brought into consideration. An owner who is found to have been negligent in caring for their dog or protecting the public from their dog may be found at fault for their dog's attack.
Sometimes a dog attack victim is found to have caused the attack. Individuals who trespass on private property, intentionally tease or aggravate a dog or behave in a manner that provokes aggressive behavior from a dog may be found at fault. Individuals who fail to take reasonable measures to protect themselves or their animals from a dog attack -- for example, trying to break up a dog fight at a dog park and being bitten in the process -- may also take some of the blame if things turn out badly.
- NOLO: A Dog Owner's Legal Defenses
- Cesar's Way: Do Biting Dogs Deserve a Second Chance?
- Christensen & Hymas: Dog Owners Are Not Always At Fault In Dog Bite Injuries
- The Law Offices of John E. Kusturiss, Jr.: Who is at Fault in Dog Attacks?
- Edgar Snyder and Associates: What to Do if Another Dog Attacks Your Dog
- K9 Magazine: The Anatomy of a Dog Attack
- Michigan Lawyer Aaron R. Larson: Michigan Dog Bite Law and Injury Prevention
- Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images News/Getty Images